Some things, SSJ4 Full Power & Super Saiyan Power are at the bottom because they're literally just 2 better forms with almost no changes, plus SSJ Power if I remember correctly only exists so Pikkon wouldn't see Super Saiyan and Full Power could literally just be SSJ4 but with other's power
Why Rage is at the bottom should be obvious, it has no explaination and is just SSJ2 but angier and with a slightly blue aura and I already said how I think it could be improved in a different post
SSJ1 Grades 2&3 are higher because at least they have a narrative purpose as steppingstones to Grade 4 and Super Saiyan 2 and as introducing the idea of them being stronger than regular SSJ1 but less useful or even useless in SSJ Grade 3's case so they work better
Tufflized Super Saiyan and Supressed Legendary Super Saiyan are fine I guess but I don't get why Tufflized Super Saiyan couldn't have just been the result of Baby taking control of Vegeta rather than a new form and Super Saiyan A-Type could have just been Super Saiyan Broly or just Z Broly powering up while staying in base or the result of being freed from the mind control
God Broly is fine but it's near identical to LSSJ3 and I would have prefered something different for Legendary Super Saiyan God
Rose 2 makes sense and I think it's a good idea but it's dragged down by the fact that SSJ2 looks basically the same as SSJ1 on everyone but Kid Gohan
Super Saiyan 3 Full Power is brought down by just looking like SSJ3 and not being unique enough, I would have preferred they make it look like SSJ Rose 3 but with the regular golden color, SSJ Berserk and Blue Controlled Berserk are literally just the regular versions of their forms but with a slightly black aura, but at least they have an explaination unlike SSJRage, that being their SSJ & Blue with some of the Ki of the Evil Saiyan form forced into them, Grade 2 & 3 are literally just SSJ1 but with more muscles and give off cringe-edgy 90s comics vibes but they have a narrative purpose so they work
Pseudo Super Saiyan is fine and I feel like it could work in the canon story as a Super Saiyan 0 it's only in the Lord Slug movie cause they didn't know what Super Saiyan was like yet
Perfect Blue is literally just the same form as Blue so why is it even on this tier list
SSJ3 is fine but the lack of eyebrows ruin it for me and it's useless now since Goku has SSJ4 in canon post Daima and in canon he also has the Super Saiyan God forms which are even stronger than SSJ4 and they're easier to use and in the GT continuity he also has SSJ4 and they're all better functionally than SSJ3 so it has no reason to be used now and it only really worked before he got better forms, and Vegeta also has the God forms in canon so he doesn't need to use SSJ3 either
True Ultra Instinct is fine and works narratively but it's just the same as the other 2 UIs
SSJ Kaioken and SSJGSSJ Kaioken are fine but they're not really seperate forms but they make sense as power ups
SSJ2, LSSJ2, and LSSJ3 are all cool but they only work for me for 1 character each (Gohan for SSJ2, Kefla for LSSJ2, and Z Broly for LSSJ3) (also for anyone with a problem with Kefla having LSS2 for any reason, I would just say that there's no reason she shouldn't since Gotenks can use SSJ3 despite neither Goten or Trunks being able to do it normally)
I really like Ultra Instinct and Ultra Ego conceptually, especially with how Ultra Instinct combines the Godly forms of Super with the series' Martial Arts roots thanks to Ultra Instinct being a Godly Martial Art that mortals need to transform to use, for Ultimate, it's a really cool and fitting idea, building off of how the whole thing for hybrid saiyans and especially Gohan is their power potential being greater than pure saiyans it makes sense that they would have this unlocked as their big final transformation, I honestly think from an in-universe perspective Goten, Trunks & Pan should get it too and I admit I think that Strongest Forms 1&2 are cool and it gives Baby a unique design when controlling Vegeta's body to set him apart from Vegeta himself, also Ultra Ego is really cool as a counterpart to Ultra Instinct rather than just giving Vegeta Ultra Instinct and it's fitting he'd have a G.o.D. counterpart. my main problem is their not really Saiyan forms, just forms with Saiyan Users that could be gotten by anyone hypothetically in the case of most of them or in the case of Strongest Form 1&2 they're Baby's forms and seem to be Tuffle forms that are like Super Saiyan 2 and 3 rather than Saiyan forms
Super Saiyan Rose 3 is cool and that's all you need sometimes, plus the mask makes up for the missing eyebrows
Big Yellow Ape, also makes sense but it's a little cringe, not super but still a little
Oozaru - the Classic
Ikari, really cool the idea of using Oozaru's power in base even if it's just the regular form with a greenish aura and yellow eyes, and it is a little weird Goku or Gohan can't use it because the form because of how they similarly lost their tail young
Evil Saiyan, it's cool, it has a unique aura, it has the cool long hair of SSJ3 but without the awful missing eyebrows and it gives Cumber & Turles a unique form and is the closest thing that we have to a demon counterpart to Super Saiyan God
Super Saiyan 4 has a cool design, it's a logical place to take Super Saiyan 3's next evolution by giving it characteristics of the Saiyan's ape like aspects even if it being achieved by turning into a Super Saiyan Oozaru is a bit stupid and it's weird Goku can use it in Daima without his tail given it's Oozaru like characteristics
The Super Saiyan God forms are overhated just for being recolors, but the idea is cool, they look cool, it opens new possibilities with the idea Saiyans can use different sources of power to evolve Super Saiyan and the idea of them getting truly Godly Powers and the recolor thing even makes sense since SSJ God has similar propertities to the user's base form and Super Saiyan Blue is created by combining it with the basic Super Saiyan form which is also a logical way to get a powerup from SSJ God like how Super Saiyan Kaioken for regular Super Saiyan and Super Saiyan 4 is for Super Saiyan 3, and I think it actually makes sense that the Super Saiyan God forms would be more simple and understated compared to SSJ3&4 and especially the original SSJG design which was over designed according to what we know about it yet that they would still have an aura of power to them
Super Saiyan Blue Evolution, I just like it, nothing much too it but I like that it has a darker blue color and the more defined muscles and unique aura althought they could have made it more unique in it's look or given us more of an explaination
Super Saiyan Rose a.k.a. cooler Blue (I don't even like Pink but I like how it looks)
SSJ Rose 3 Full Power (Man I wish we got SSJ Blue 2&3) anyway it fixes the eyebrow problem and the tail's a cool addition
Beast, a cool idea and the design's not bad once you get used to it, my main problem is it's a little confusing because Ultimate is already supposed to be Gohan's maximum potential, but it's still cool especially with how it's a throwback to SSJ2 Gohan
Legendary Super Saiyan (Or the Demonic Saiyan as the DBS Manga calls it) is just cool, I must say though I prefer the canon version of it being a mutant Saiyan form and the source of the Universe 6 Saiyan's equalevent to the Legend of the Super Saiyan just not called a Super Saiyan, with Broly being the Universe 7 version of this form since the original idea of it being the True form of Super Saiyan took away from Goku on Namek in the Frieza Saga by saying he didn't actually become a real Super Saiyan
Super Saiyan 1 is the most iconic, it's the simplest SSJ form, it has the best unlocking moment and just in general it's simple & cool and opened the door to a ton of new possibilities
Super Saiyan 4 Limit Breaker... come on, it's Super Saiyan God Super Saiyan 4 basically even if it's never explicitly called that, what's not to love plus Xeno Goku & Vegeta are cool and SSJ4LB Xeno Vegito has my favorite design of any Saiyan
This is all my opinion you can disagree and looking back writing all this now a few forms I might swap around but overall this is my personal tier list, my favorites are the God Forms, LSSJ, SSJ1&4 and Ultra Instinct and Ego with Beast not far behind, here is a link to the original tier list
Create a Dragon Ball Saiyan Forms and Transformations Tier List - TierMaker
Edit: Ignore the teen part on the cool on one person tier, it originally said only cool on Teen Gohan or something to that effect but I changed it so it could include LSSJ2&3 so just ignore that 1 word it is literally only there because I missed it when editing the tier
